Marie Claire’s ‘Hunger Diaries’ writes off 6 healthy eating bloggers
Photo by Stephen Lewis (MarieClaire.com)
I was surprised to come across a Marie Claire article online disparaging the work of six popular healthy eating bloggers, several of whom I have followed for almost a year.
The article, which also appears in the November issue of the magazine, paints these women — Kath Younger (who blogs at katheats.com), Tina Haupert (carrotsncake.com), Meghann Anderson (graduatemeghann.com), Caitlin Boyle (healthytippingpoint.com), Heather Pare (hangrypants.com) and Jenna Weber (eatliverun.com) — as food and fitness extremists who have unhealthy obsessions with their physical appearances and the food they’re putting into their bodies.
The bloggers are lambasted for advocating healthier eating, when “in fact,” as the writer Katie Drummond suggests, they are putting readers and themselves in danger with their unhealthy approach to food and fitness.
The article is unfortunate and unfairly slanted.
In reading these healthy eating/living/fitness blogs, I have garnered inspiration and motivation for my own daily walk (and, of course, for this blog), as I’m sure many other women have.
The women who write the blogs offer up healthy recipes (and some not-so-healthy), keep food journals of what they eat throughout the day, post pictures, share what exercise they’ve done and offer small glimpses into their personal lives. They write honestly about their successes and hopes, as well as their struggles and frustrations.
Most importantly, they make clear that they in no way are the last word on how to maintain a healthy lifestyle. They are offering examples from their own lives of exercise and diet failures and victories.
No, these girls are not dietitians (except for Younger) or fitness experts — but they don’t tout themselves as such, either.
I’m sure it’s possible that some unhealthy or struggling readers could come across these blogs and think they need to follow the bloggers’ routines to a T without care or concern for their own needs and well-being.
And I’m also positive there are blogs being written by girls who are truly unhealthy and who promote distorted eating and exercise.
In reading these blogs, though, I am quite sure that is not the goal of any of these bloggers. Sure, there are times when they come across as compulsive about what they eat or don’t eat. There are times when they seem to exercise too much and eat too little.
But in reality, they are just like the majority of us. Struggling to find a balance each day, wanting to live healthily, striving for a fit body.
Have you read the Marie Claire article? Do you follow any health or fitness blogs? What’s your take on the issue?

